Roger Waters Repeatedly Tried to Discuss Israel and BDS with Thom Yorke
“They’re still killing the children Thom under your Radiohead flag. Come out of your dark basket Thom and stand with me and Ken Loach and Brian Eno out here in the light.”
Famed English rock band Radiohead is no stranger to controversy – at least around one subject: Israel.
In 2017, for instance, they notoriously rejected calls from the Palestinian-led Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement to cancel their planned gig in Tel Aviv, drawing widespread backlash.
Last year, the band’s guitarist, Jonny Greenwood, who is married to an Israeli, played a show in Tel Aviv with Israeli musician Dudu Tassa, a day after reportedly attending “protests calling for the release of the hostages in Gaza.”
“Last Sunday night, while Israeli forces bombed displaced Palestinians sheltering in tents in Rafah, Gaza – burning men, women, children and babies alive – a short drive away, Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood performed a concert in apartheid Tel Aviv,” said the BDS movement in a statement at the time.
“Regardless of excuses, crossing the Palestinian picket line and performing in apartheid Israel during its genocide against 2.3 million Palestinians in Gaza is to consciously whitewash – or artwash – Israel’s genocide and underlying 76-year-old regime of settler-colonial apartheid,” the statement said.
“Palestinians unequivocally condemn Jonny Greenwood’s shameful artwashing of Israel’s genocide,” they continued. “We call for peaceful, creative pressure on his band Radiohead to convincingly distance itself from this blatant complicity in the crime of crimes or face grassroots measures.”
Greenwood, for his part, put out a response accusing them of “urging the silencing” of “this – or any – artistic effort by Israeli Jews,” and stating that it “feels unprogressive” to him.
A few months later, in October 2024, an audience member at one of Radiohead frontman Thom Yorke’s solo shows in Melbourne, Australia, shouted out to him:
“What will it take for you to condemn the Israeli genocide of Gaza? Already 200,000! Half of them are children! How can you be silent?”
Radiohead singer storms off after call to 'condemn Gaza genocide'
'What will it take for you to condemn the Israeli genocide in Gaza. Already 200,000, half of them are children, how can you be silent.' Radiohead singer Thom Yorke storms off stage after a protestor challenged his… pic.twitter.com/toJ9OtVbz8
“Come up here and say that,” Yorke said. “Come up on the f**king stage and say what you wanna say. Don’t stand there like a coward. Come here and say it.”
He then accused the protestor of wanting to “piss on everybody’s night,” and walked off the stage. (He returned several minutes later and performed the song “Karma Police.”)
Thom ‘Fills in the Blanks’
On Friday, roughly seven months after the “Australian incident,” Yorke posted a new statement on Gaza to the social media platform Bluesky. It begins:
Some guy shouting at me from the dark last year when I was picking up a guitar to sing the final song alone in front of 9000 people in Melbourne didn’t really seem like the best moment to discuss the unfolding humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza.
Afterwards I remained in shock that my supposed silence was somehow being taken as complicity, and I struggled to find an adequate way to respond to this and to carry on with the rest of the shows on the tour.
That silence, my attempt to show respect for all those who are suffering and those who have died, and to not trivialise it in a few words, has allowed other opportunistic groups to use intimidation and defamation to fill in the blanks, and I regret giving them this chance. This has had a heavy toll on my mental health.
From there he says it should be “self evident” from his music, artwork, and lyrics that he “could not possibly support any form of extremism or dehumanisation of others,” and encourages “critical thinking beyond borders, the commonality of love and experience and free creative expression.”
He then states that he is going “fill in the blanks now, so we’re nice and clear,” and proceeds to spend about fifteen paragraphs weighing in on the genocide in Gaza (although he doesn’t call it that), Netanyahu, Hamas, “online manipulation,” “deliberate polarization,” “social media witch hunts… on either side,” and so on.
Many people “online” are not impressed.
“The full Thom Yorke statement after 20 months of genocide is pretty much what you’d expect,” said writer Caitlin Johnstone on X. “Shitlib both-sidesing, victim LARPing, blaming Netanyahu for Gaza while whining and denouncing ‘the unquestioning Free Palestine refrain that surrounds us all’ for being too nice to Hamas.”
“Yes, Thom Yorke, you are the real victim of the extermination campaign of all Palestinians because your own fans wanted you to use your immense privilege to say Israel should stop,” said streamer and political commentator Hasan Piker in another viral post.
The full Thom Yorke statement after 20 months of genocide is pretty much what you'd expect. Shitlib both-sidesing, victim LARPing, blaming Netanyahu for Gaza while whining and denouncing "the unquestioning Free Palestine refrain that surrounds us all" for being too nice to Hamas. pic.twitter.com/68YvWPJ2GH
“Turns out all the profound meaning I projected into Radiohead’s music was my own,” wrote musician Saul Williams. “F**k this dude to all eternity. What a creep.” The post currently has over 21,000 likes.
“I thought that ‘I’m a creep’ was a poetic take on the adolescent experience of loneliness, heartache and alienation,” commented human rights activist and barrister Ousman Noor. “Didn’t realise it was Thom Yorke just making an announcement.”
Waters and Yorke
Pink Floyd co-founder Roger Waters – a longtime supporter of the BDS movement – tried years ago to get Thom Yorke to use his “important voice” to help the Palestinians, or to at least stop playing shows in Israel and giving “tacit approval” to their system of apartheid, subjugation, occupation, and colonization.
In February of 2017, he sent Yorke the following email:
Dear Thom
I don’t know you personally, but I know you because of your work; you have an important voice. Some of my Palestinian friends know I’m working with Nigel Godrich and have figured out that in consequence I can get a message to you. The word is out that you’re planning to do a gig in Tel Aviv. My friends have asked me to write to you before they start their public campaign.
We in the human rights movement are deeply concerned that Radiohead plan to cross the BDS picket line and perform in Israel. To do so gives tacit approval to the Israeli government’s systematic colonization of Palestinian land and subjugation of the Palestinian people, formalizing the status quo of the occupation into a unified apartheid state.
Eli Wiesel, the famous Jewish writer, holocaust survivor and Nobel Peace Lauriat who died last year said many things of note. Here are a few:
“We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.”
“There may be times when we are powerless to prevent injustice, but there must never be a time when we fail to protest.”
“No human race is superior; no religious faith is inferior. All collective judgments are wrong. Only racists make them.”
“To remain silent and indifferent is the greatest sin of all.”
I won’t bang on, but as far as we know we only get one go at life, only one chance to stand up for human rights, in solidarity with all our brothers and sisters, irrespective of their nationality, race or religion. The lives of a Jewish child and a Palestinian child are equally precious.
Hey Thom I’m sorry, my letter wasn’t meant to be confrontational. I was reaching out to see if we could have the conversation that you talk about in your reply. Can we? Love R.
“Thom did not reply,” according to Waters. After waiting over two weeks, and, he says, feeling “somewhat exasperated,” he followed up on March 3, 2017:
“Uncomfortableness”
Dear Thom
Some truth. I had a minor op this morning on my shoulder and in consequence my left arm is temporarily dead, numb, paralyzed. It is a horrible feeling. It’s my limb but I have no control over it.
I attach a photo in which I’m mouthing “Here boy” to you in a soothing placatory manner, imagining you snarling at the effrontery of me writing to you again. You may retire to your corner to snarl, in which case………gnash …….. snarl…….grrrrr…………..click!
If not, and I hope not, there is more. Firstly, here-under is the reply I drafted to your response to my original letter but was warned off from sending. Again I apologize for trying to baby you, as grown men we at least owe one another some truth. Here’s the letter I didn’t send.
Hey Thom
I’m sorry, there was no threat intended in my letter, if I gave that impression I apologize. In your Email you say,
”Normally I would expect a conversation first”.
My letter is intended as the start of a conversation. The conversation is about human rights and whether the people who call themselves Palestinians should, or should not, have any. Many people believe that they should have the same basic human rights under international law as you or I or anyone else. At the moment they don’t. They have had no rights since 1967, since when they have lived under military occupation. In your Email you also say,
“I knew nothing about this line we have now crossed, no one on their side wants to show us the respect of a discussion.”
So, in order to explain “the line” that you may cross, I need to bring up BDS, (Boycott Divestment and Sanctions). BDS is a global protest movement started in 2005 by Palestinian civil society, as a form of non-violent resistance to the Israeli occupation. Part of this resistance to the occupation is a cultural boycott of Israel. There is a picket line that musicians and intellectuals and academics who support human rights will not cross. They will not perform or lecture or receive prizes in Israel until such time as Israel agrees to abide by international law. That is all. To be clear BDS is not an attempt to destroy the State of Israel, it is about securing basic human rights for a beleaguered people. I’m not sure what you mean by:
”no one on their side wants to show us the respect of discussion.”
If by ‘their side’ you mean BDS, I know the leaders of BDS and they would be eager to have a discussion with you. I can put you in touch with them or, if you prefer, I would be more than happy to have that discussion with you myself.
Secondly, I can only imagine how powerlessness feels, hence photo.
Thirdly, this conversation is too important to die stillborn, both me preaching from my high horse and you snarling from your basket are dumb! Whoops there I go again, or not. The BDS movement is showing you no disrespect.
Fourthly, (no more apologies for being preachy) I quote Michael Bennett the Seattle Seahawk football player, who has recently declined an invitation to visit Israel on the grounds that his visit would be used to promote and legitimize Israel and its policies, Like 1968 Olympian John Carlos always says,
“There is no partial commitment to justice. You are either in or you’re out.”
Michael Bennet is in. So am I.
Lastly, one of my friends in Palestine sent me a video today which I shall forward. This lady is in too. Your reputation is that you’re super smart and super difficult. Someone recently suggested to me that maybe some people think of you the way some people thought of me 25 years ago? Maybe? Whatever, this discussion needs you. People from “their side” are desperate to have you in the discussion, their lives and Israeli lives too, depend on it.
Love
R.
Yorke replied:
that’s it
i quit
ask your friend Eno to read the letter from Jonny
i was looking for a reason to quit making music and this business and your letter has been the final tipping point
so
thanks
(spell checked by GCHQ)
“I can only assume Thom was being ironic/sarcastic?” Waters says. “Anyway, we, in BDS shook our heads and went back to work, a quiet dark pall of disbelief and disillusion hanging silent in the wake of Radiohead’s rejection of our approaches.”
‘Throwing Shit’
A couple months later, in April 2017, Waters and dozens of other prominent figures, including Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Thurston Moore of Sonic Youth, Tunde Adebimpe of TV on the Radio, and English filmmaker Ken Loach, published an open letter to the band members of Radiohead:
Dear Thom Yorke, Jonny Greenwood, Colin Greenwood, Ed O’Brien and Philip Selway,
You’re listed to play Tel Aviv in July this year.
We’d like to ask you to think again – because by playing in Israel you’ll be playing in a state where, UN rapporteurs say, ‘a system of apartheid has been imposed on the Palestinian people’.
We understand you’ve been approached already by Palestinian campaigners. They’ve asked you to respect their call for a cultural boycott of Israel, and you’ve turned them down. Since Radiohead campaigns for freedom for the Tibetans, we’re wondering why you’d turn down a request to stand up for another people under foreign occupation. And since Radiohead fronted a gig for the 50th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, we’re wondering why you’d ignore a call to stand against the denial of those rights when it comes to the Palestinians.
Radiohead once issued a statement saying: ‘Without the work of organisations like Amnesty International, the Universal Declaration would be mere rhetoric’. You’ve clearly read Amnesty’s reports, so you’ll know that Israel denies freedom to the Palestinians under occupation, who can’t live where they want, can’t travel as they please, who get detained (and often tortured) without charge or trial, and can’t even use Facebook without surveillance, censorship and arrest.
In asking you not to perform in Israel, Palestinians have appealed to you to take one small step to help pressure Israel to end its violation of basic rights and international law. Surely if making a stand against the politics of division, of discrimination and of hate means anything at all, it means standing against it everywhere – and that has to include what happens to Palestinians every day. Otherwise the rest is, to use your words, ‘mere rhetoric’.
You may think that sharing the bill with Israeli musicians Dudu Tassa & the Kuwaitis, who play Jewish-Arabic music, will make everything OK. It won’t, any more than ‘mixed’ performances in South Africa brought closer the end of the apartheid regime. Please do what artists did in South Africa’s era of oppression: stay away, until apartheid is over.
In early June 2017, Yorke “broke his silence” in Rolling Stone with a response to his critics in the BDS movement, writing in part that it is, “deeply distressing that they choose to, rather than engage with us personally, throw shit at us in public.”
“Well that, Thom, is a porky pie,” Waters wrote to Yorke a few days later after quoting that line. “I made every attempt to engage with you personally, would still like to engage, as I have repeatedly said this conversation is too important not to have, it is a matter of life and death on a daily basis.”
He continued in the same June 5, 2017 message:
“Not to talk is not an option.”
Throwing shit is not an option either.
On Monday it will be the 50th anniversary of the military occupation of Palestine by Israel. 50 years living under the jackboot, 50 years with no civil rights, 50 years of no recourse to the law, 50 years of apartheid. There are many brave Israeli Jews who speak out against the policies of the current undemocratic extremist theocratic government of Israel. When you are there, speak with those brave voices, engage in the conversation, I think you may find many would have preferred you to respect the picket line. The picket line exists to shine a light on the predicament of the occupied people of Palestine and to promote equal civil rights for all the people living between the Jordan River and the sea no matter what their nationality, race or religion. All human life is sacred, every child is our child, exceptionalism is our enemy.
Roger Waters
Thom’s ‘Dark Basket’
Fast-forward to December 6, 2024, over seven years after their first email exchange about Israel, and a little more than two months after Thom Yorke’s walked off the stage in Austalia after an audience member urged him to condemn Israel’s genocide in Gaza. Waters to Yorke:
They’re still killing the children Thom under your Radiohead flag. Come out of your dark basket Thom and stand with me and Ken Loach and Brian Eno out here in the light.
Waters then quoted some of the lyrics from his own 1990 song, “Too Much Rope”:
You don’t have to be a Jew
To disapprove of murder
Tears burn my eyes
Moslem or Christian
Mullah or Pope
Preacher or poet
Who was it wrote
Give any one species
Too much rope
And they’ll fuck it up.
Six month later, we apparently now have Yorke’s reply.
For those who need to know.. let me fill in the blanks
“What you have to understand about Thom, obviously, is that he was sitting there happily on a pedestal,” Waters said in February 2025.
There are a “huge number of fans of Radiohead” who not only love Yorke’s music, Waters added, but who also “think, or thought,” that he “somehow was part of the resistence against ‘Big Brother’ and ‘The Man.’ ”
“[Thom is] obviously very, very, deeply insecure,” he opined in another interview while reflecting on their exchanges. “He obviously thinks he’s very bright, but he’s not… so he can’t actually have a conversation.”
Commenting on Jonny Greenwood’s past statement about wanting to “reach an understanding between the two sides of this apparently endless conflict,” Waters said:
It’s complete bulls**t. Obviously. They have—there is no argument to be made. There is the oppressed, and the oppressor. The oppressed are the indigenous people of Palestine. The oppressors are the settler colonial visitors from North America and [northern] Europe. . . . The oppressors are murdering all of the oppressed people so they can steal their furniture, and their houses, and their olive trees, and their hills, and their streams, and their water, and their land, and their birthright.
“There is nothing difficult to understand,” Waters said. “It is not a ‘conflict.’ It is a GE-NO-CIDE, Thom and Jonny. And you are supporting it.”
WAIT! Very quickly before you go: Decensored News is an independent, reader-supported publication. If you value our work, please help us grow and produce more of it with a monthly or one-time contribution. We can't do this work without you. Part of this story was originally published as a thread on X. For more reporting like this, follow us on multiple platforms and bookmark the website. Thank you for your support and interest.